
Covers - that is to say, songs originally performed by one artist that another artist recorded a different version of - are a funny phenomenon. The practice of covering songs has produced some excellent tracks, as well as some, er, pretty terrible ones that only serve to sully the good name of original.
But some covers are so good that nobody even remembers the originals - these songs are the reason why new artists return to old standards so often. True, everyone knows that “I Heard It Through the Grapevine” was made famous by Marvin Gaye, and that Bruce Springsteen originally did “Blinded by the Light” (sans the hilariously slurred “deuce/douche”), but it takes something truly memorable for a band or artist to make someone else’s song truly their own. In that vein, here’s the top five covers that most people would never guess were covers.
5) The Sundays - “Wild Horses.” A minor hit for The Rolling Stones in 1971, “Wild Horses” in its original incarnation was a cheesy, over-the-top folksy song that had Mick Jagger adopting a horrible faux-country drawl. ’90s band The Sundays removed the cheese (and the drums) and reworked the song into an equally minor, but much more memorable, alt-rock radio staple that instantly made everyone who heard it forget the awful original.
4) 10,000 Maniacs - “Because The Night.” In a landmark live performance on MTV Unplugged, Natalie Merchant and crew took this 1978 Patti Smith single and gave it a moody, slightly unsettling, and decidedly epic vibe that the Smith version of the song was sorely missing. As a result, a generation grew up hearing this version on the radio without even knowing who Patti Smith is.
3) Led Zeppelin - “When The Levee Breaks.” Easily one of the best songs that Zeppelin ever recorded (in my opinion, at least), this tune is actually a reworked version of an obscure blues song written about the Great Mississippi Flood of 1927. The best improvement - again, in my opinion - comes in the form of John Bonham’s echoing drums, which were played at the bottom of a three-story stairwell with the recording mics at the top. How cool is that?
2) Soft Cell - “Tainted Love.” Originally recorded in 1964 by soul singer Gloria Jones, “Tainted Love” found its true voice when ’80s new-wave pioneers Soft Cell recorded the version that everyone knows in 1981. As a result, every single post-1980 cover of the song seems to include that half-catchy, half-annoying “da! da!” synth part that glues itself to your mind’s ear and won’t let go. Ever.
1) Aretha Franklin - “Respect.” Aretha’s chart-topping breakout 1967 hit was actually recorded two years earlier by Otis Redding - though the latter only made it to number 35 on the pop singles charts. Bet’cha didn’t know that.